- Critic 0.3.0: the hooks look up every disposition citation in the verified Discovery package (app/evidence.py). An unresolved citation fails K-02 and rejects the disposition; whether the records support the basis stays the model's judgement. - Critic 0.3.1: K-02 judges a disposition's citations together (evidence_ref is the primary record), ADR 0013 addendum. - Profiler 0.1.1: represents edges are not dependencies (ADR 0012, now covering ALZ-ASM-02). - Scaffold: builds every prompt before deleting anything. - Tests on Discovery run exec_58ba6a71d00b's package and runs 007 and 009 (15). - Run exec_49e355141382 (RUN-ASM-AZURE-012) passed on crucible-kab-dev. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
ALZ-F02 Assessment & Disposition: individual agents
Six declarative KAB agents, one per ALZ-ASM story, chained by one KAB workflow, behind a code-only intake step that
checks the Discovery package first (ADR 0008). They take an approved Discovery run's package and a rate card. For every application they produce a readiness profile, a migration risk score,
advisory security findings (in-cloud estates only), a 7R disposition with an indicative TCO, and an independent
critic's verdict. The Engagement Lead approves the verdict as disposition_signoff.
Requirements: ADO Feature 3214442, stories 3214459–3214464. The sub-agent pattern for this Feature isn't built yet, and the two are kept separate.
The workflow
workflows/cp1-alz-assessment-individual.json, built by scripts/build_workflow.py:
| Step | What | Inputs from |
|---|---|---|
a1 |
Artifacts: the Discovery run's package, by exact id | The run (artifact_ids) |
p1 |
Parse Assessment Files over a1's records |
a1.artifacts |
s0 |
Assessment Intake (ADR 0008): checks the package in code (one package, every part's sha256, complete, critic pass, the named Discovery run); a refused package fails the run here | p1 |
s1 |
Assessment Planner (ALZ-ASM-01): checks the preconditions and plans, or refuses | p1, the run's rate_card_document, after s0 |
s2 |
Cloud Readiness Profiler (ALZ-ASM-02) | p1, s1 |
s3 |
Migration Risk Scorer (ALZ-ASM-03) | p1, s1 |
s4 |
Security Posture Assessment (ALZ-ASM-05): not applicable on-premises | p1, s1 |
s5 |
7R Disposition & TCO (ALZ-ASM-04) | p1, the run's rate_card_document, s1, s2, s3, s4 |
s6 |
Assessment Critic & Sign-off Router (ALZ-ASM-06): approval step | All of the above |
s2, s3 and s4 run in parallel.
Starting a run
-
Choose a Discovery run whose critic verdict is
passand which was approved. Note its execution id and the artifact id of its package step output (F01 ADR 0020). KAB names a run's step artifacts by position, not step id: the package is{execution_id}_step_12in the current Discovery workflow. Select only that one artifact: the intake refuses anything else. -
Start the workflow with these values:
engagement_idrun_iddiscovery_execution_iddiscovery_approval_ref: the decision record approving the Discovery runartifact_ids: the Discovery package artifactrate_card_document: the rate card's JSON, as text (ADR 0009). There's no upload: an uploaded file would reach the parse step and be read in place of the Discovery package
Alternatively, fix the artifact ids in the export with
python3 scripts/build_workflow.py --artifact-id <id> .... -
Expect the intake to fail the run if the package is missing, changed, incomplete, from a failed critic, or from another Discovery run or engagement: its error lists every reason.
-
Expect a refusal, not a plan, if no approval is given or there's no rate card. The critic then fails the run.
Rate card
The rate card is a JSON file with rate_card_id, currency and items. Each item has:
rate_idcategorydescriptionannual_rateequivalent_for: the services, products or asset classes it can replacelicence_terms
An illustrative sample for the Meridian Retail Group estate is in workflows/cases/meridian-assessment/rate-card.json. TCO is indicative; the Business Case (ALZ-BCS-02) gives the authoritative figure.
MCP servers
None added. Only ALZ-ASM-02 and ALZ-ASM-05 call tools, all read-only and all on existing servers in
mcp-servers/: azure-discovery, aws-discovery and gcp-discovery, including their
Well-Architected guidance tools. All three must be registered and healthy before those two agents can start (ADR 0007). The other four agents call no tool.
Decisions
The decision records cover how this pattern meets or interprets the stories:
- Scoring as prompt rules that the critic recalculates.
- Discovery's outputs arriving as parsed text, with the run id and approval as run inputs.
- The rate card format.
- Sign-off as the critic step's approval.
- The models used.
- The tool-call check this pattern can't make.
- The MCP servers that must be registered first.
Status
Built and checked offline: six folders pass check_agents.py, the workflow export builds, and all 25 declared tools
exist on their servers. Nothing is deployed, and no eval case or workflow run has been executed yet. The remaining
steps are in .agents/PLAN.md.