Files
gcp_solution_architecture_a…/.agents/plans/iter-08-terraform-modules/steps/step-1-to-5.md
Jonathan Boniface 10d23a5f91 docs: record the first runs with and without Terraform modules
Case 03's request once each way, both at 100%. Opted in, a module was used
for private Cloud SQL only and 14 Checks were met through its inputs. The
difference in time and cost between the two runs is their Revisions, not
the modules.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-09 22:47:09 +01:00

6.4 KiB

Steps 1 to 5 — Implementation Detail

Built on 2026-10-09. No Execution has run with it.

1. Which modules

terraform.modules.namespaces in the provider bundle lists the registry namespaces a module may come from; for Google Cloud, terraform-google-modules. TerraformRunner.validate and .plan refuse, before Terraform runs:

  • a source that is not <allowed namespace>/<name>/<provider>, optionally with //path: so any Git or HTTP URL, a GitHub shorthand, a local path, or another namespace;
  • a version that is not one exact version;
  • a module written in .tf.json.

With no namespace listed every module call is refused. The evaluation's own validation uses the same list, and only for a case that opts in.

The source the owner gave is a GitHub organisation; the registry namespace of the same name is what Terraform is pointed at, because the registry serves a fixed archive for a version and terraform init needs no Git.

2. What a module accepts

terraform_module(source, version, find) reads the public Terraform registry: a module's or submodule's inputs (required first, with type and description), its outputs and its submodules. It compares the module's provider requirements with the versions the bundle pins and says "NOT USABLE" when they exclude it. Only allowed namespaces can be looked up. Answers are cached for the life of the process.

It makes one new outbound call, to registry.terraform.io, which terraform init already reaches.

3. The Skill

skills/google-cloud-iac-modules/: when to use a module (it is in the table, it replaces three or more dependent resources, and every Check on the Elements it covers can be met through an input), and four references with a validated example each.

For Module Version
VPC, subnets, firewall rules, Cloud NAT network, cloud-nat 18.3.1, 7.1.0
Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL on a private address sql-db//modules/postgresql, //modules/private_service_access 28.3.0
A Cloud Storage bucket with retention, lifecycle, encryption, grants cloud-storage//modules/simple_bucket 12.4.1
A key ring, keys and grants kms 4.2.1

tests/test_iac_modules.py runs each example through terraform validate with the patterns Skill's versions file, and checks that every module call is from an allowed namespace at the version the table gives. It needs the network and is skipped without it.

The Skill is named in the bundle under terraform.modules.skill, not among any role's Skills. See step 5 for who is given it.

4. Checks through a module

A Check stays worded about the resource. implementation.json gives the module and the input that meets it, such as module.database.ip_configuration.ipv4_enabled. When no input sets what a Check needs, the module does not fit and the resources are written directly. The validator reads the input's value and confirms with the lookup what it sets, or what its default is.

This is instruction, in the Skills and the two role files. Nothing in code verifies that a module input does what a Check says: that would need a plan against a real project.

5. Opt-in per Execution

Infrastructure code is plain resources unless the Execution opts in.

  • ExecutionEngine.start(terraform_modules=...): true, false, or unset. Unset, a Change request does as its Baseline did, and any other Execution takes TERRAFORM_MODULES (off). Opting in is refused when the provider's bundle lists no sources.
  • Callers: terraform_modules in the /generate body, in A2A message metadata, and on an evaluation case.
  • Opted in: the roles that carry the terraform_module tool (the IaC author and the validator) are given the modules Skill, and their context says terraform_modules: true.
  • Not opted in: those roles get neither the Skill nor the tool, and any module block is refused by terraform_validate and terraform_plan with a message saying to write the resources directly. The refusal is in code (MODULES_OPTED_IN in app/tools/modules.py, set when a Specialist starts), not only in instructions.
  • execution.json records terraform_modules.

Reference routing (iteration 5 step 8) does not choose within the modules Skill, because it is not among a role's Skills at start-up.

Known limits

  • Modules also bring providers the bundle does not pin (google-beta, random, null), at whatever version their constraints allow.
  • The schema review and the target architect's lookups still describe resources. A Check's wording is unaffected by whether a module later creates the resource.
  • A module version in the catalogue goes stale; nothing flags a newer one.

Tests: tests/tools/test_modules.py (24), tests/test_iac_modules.py (6), tests/execution/test_terraform_modules.py (7).

Run on 2026-10-09

Case 03's request, once each way, side by side (20261009T210931Z plain, 20261009T210935Z opted in as case-07-approved-modules). Both completed at 100%.

Plain resources Modules opted in
Minutes 35 22
Tokens 5.66 million 3.08 million
Cost, about $5.50 $3.17
Revisions of the Target architecture 3 1
Checks, all passed 77 54
Module calls / resources / lines of Terraform 0 / 35 / 555 2 / 25 / 448
Design quality score 0.82 0.62

The difference in time and cost is the Revisions, not the modules. The two runs produced different designs before any code was written: 77 Checks against 54, three Revisions against one. One run each way cannot say modules are cheaper.

What the opted-in run does show:

  • The IaC author used a module for one thing, private Cloud SQL (sql-db//modules/postgresql with //modules/private_service_access, 28.3.0), and wrote the network, load balancer, Cloud Run, storage, secrets, IAM and monitoring as plain resources. A VPC with one subnet did not get the network module.
  • 14 of 54 Checks are met through module inputs, each recorded as module.cloud_sql.<input>; the validator passed all 14 citing the input's value.
  • terraform_module was called four times by the author and once by the validator. No module was refused, and the code validated.
  • For a Check met by leaving an input unset, the validator's evidence is that the module falls back to its default. That rests on the module's documentation.

The plain run was given neither the Skill nor the tool, and wrote no module.

The design quality score of 0.62 is below the bar of 0.67. It is scored on the design recommendations, written before any code.