The evaluation (both cases three times: report, results, spread, each run's Deliverables and lesson candidates) and the hand-off through the Orchestration engine (report, the document of links, both agents' kept files and records). Benchmark cases only, all fictional; no machine paths, and the links carry no signatures. Other runs stay ignored. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
244 lines
17 KiB
JSON
244 lines
17 KiB
JSON
{
|
|
"execution_id": "case-02-from-architecture-r1",
|
|
"customer_case": "case-08-landing-zone",
|
|
"status": "completed_with_warnings",
|
|
"role_skills": {
|
|
"capability-modeller": [
|
|
"operating-capabilities",
|
|
"operating-chain"
|
|
],
|
|
"operating-model-architect": [
|
|
"operating-capabilities",
|
|
"operating-chain",
|
|
"rate-card"
|
|
],
|
|
"operations-analyst": [
|
|
"operating-scoping",
|
|
"operating-chain"
|
|
],
|
|
"orchestrator": [],
|
|
"packager": [
|
|
"operating-guide"
|
|
],
|
|
"reply-writer": [],
|
|
"scope-analyst": [
|
|
"operating-scoping"
|
|
],
|
|
"validator": [
|
|
"operating-chain"
|
|
]
|
|
},
|
|
"skill_versions": {
|
|
"operating-capabilities": "49a7e66857a1",
|
|
"operating-chain": "ec53ad8875e6",
|
|
"operating-guide": "85b48d5998da",
|
|
"operating-scoping": "08da33f8cddf",
|
|
"rate-card": "f86d17a9bcce"
|
|
},
|
|
"candidates": [
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "revision",
|
|
"deliverable": "target_operating_model",
|
|
"reason": "OC-2 failed: The check requires 'immediate failover traffic reception', but Capability C-9 is scoped for 'governing the 4-hour disaster recovery automation logic', meaning it cannot provide immediate failover as designed.; OC-12 failed: The check requires roles to be 'continuously rightsized', but Capability C-11 is designed to execute 'periodic least-privilege adjustments', which cannot meet the continuous requirement.; SC-change-S-2 failed: Dedicated Private Hybrid Connectivity Gateway (S-2) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.; SC-change-S-3 failed: Centralised Outbound Traffic Inspection and Egress Boundary (S-3) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.; SC-change-S-6 failed: Federated Identity and Role Governance Authority (S-6) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.; SC-change-S-8 failed: Platform Telemetry and Operational Alerting Engine (S-8) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.; SC-change-S-9 failed: Financial Governance and Budget Enforcement Monitor (S-9) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.",
|
|
"requested_by": "orchestrator"
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "revision",
|
|
"deliverable": "capability_model",
|
|
"reason": "Check OC-2 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (The check requires maintaining an active warm standby ready to receive failover traffic, but Capability C-9 is scoped for 'governing the 4-hour disaster recovery automation logic', meaning it cannot provide immediate failover as designed. Capability C-9 should be revised to govern immediate failover traffic reception.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason. Check SC-change-S-2 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (Dedicated Private Hybrid Connectivity Gateway (S-2) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason. Check SC-change-S-3 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (Centralised Outbound Traffic Inspection and Egress Boundary (S-3) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason. Check SC-change-S-6 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (Federated Identity and Role Governance Authority (S-6) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason. Check SC-change-S-8 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (Platform Telemetry and Operational Alerting Engine (S-8) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason. Check SC-change-S-9 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (Financial Governance and Budget Enforcement Monitor (S-9) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason.",
|
|
"requested_by": "orchestrator"
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "revision",
|
|
"deliverable": "target_operating_model",
|
|
"reason": "OC-11 failed: Capability C-7 focuses on configuration state and data residency alignment, but does not cover optimizing carbon-free energy utilization based on regional scores. The Check should be mapped to a deployment capability like C-5 or C-6, or C-7 should be updated.",
|
|
"requested_by": "orchestrator"
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "revision",
|
|
"deliverable": "capability_model",
|
|
"reason": "Check OC-11 failed in two validations in a row and may not be implementable as written (The check requires automated deployments to optimize carbon-free energy utilization, and is mapped to C-6. However, C-6's basis only covers managing automated deployment pipelines to deliver foundational updates rapidly and reliably, without mentioning carbon-free energy optimization. C-6 should be updated to include this optimization.). Rewrite it so it can be met, or remove it with a reason.",
|
|
"requested_by": "orchestrator"
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "revision",
|
|
"deliverable": "target_operating_model",
|
|
"reason": "OC-3 failed: Capability C-7 focuses on tracking infrastructure state files and ensuring PCI-DSS v4.0 baseline alignment, but does not mention auditing for UK/EU data residency. Data residency is instead covered by C-21. Capability C-7 should be updated to include auditing data residency state, or the Check should be re-mapped to C-21.; OC-18 failed: Capability C-1 covers triage and managing priority incidents, but does not explicitly mention conducting a written review for every Priority 1 incident. The capability basis should be updated to include post-incident written reviews.; OC-21 failed: Capability C-4 covers fulfilling non-standard operational requests, but does not explicitly state that each kind of foundation service request has a stated way to ask and a stated time to fulfil (e.g., maintaining a service request catalogue). The capability basis should be updated to include maintaining stated request methods and fulfilment times.; OC-23 failed: Capability C-6 covers resolving deployment failures and managing automated pipelines, but does not explicitly guarantee a rollback capability within the 4-hour RTO. The capability should be updated to cover rapid rollback procedures.",
|
|
"requested_by": "orchestrator"
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "revision_limit",
|
|
"deliverable": "target_operating_model",
|
|
"reason": "OC-2 failed: The check requires the secondary region to be 'continuously maintained' as an active warm standby, but Capability C-9 is configured for 'business' hours, meaning maintenance cannot be continuous (24x7). C-9 should be 24x7 or another capability should provide continuous maintenance.; OC-4 failed: The check requires validation within 10 weeks, but Capability C-16 covers managing the roadmap without explicitly mentioning the 10-week requirement (which is instead mentioned in C-18). C-16 must mention the 10-week validation or the check mapped to C-18.; OC-9 failed: The check requires that expenditure does not exceed target allocations without 'documented operational sign-off', but Capability C-14 only mentions 'escalating anomalies' and does not explicitly guarantee documented sign-off.; OC-12 failed: The check requires identity permissions to be 'continuously reviewed', but Capability C-11 operates only during 'business' hours, meaning reviews cannot be continuous. C-11 must be 24x7.; OC-17 failed: The check requires verifiable alignment with DORA, PCI-DSS v4.0, and ISO 27001. Capability C-7 only ensures alignment with PCI-DSS v4.0 baseline configurations, completely missing DORA and ISO 27001 controls."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "OC-2",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires 'immediate failover traffic reception', but Capability C-9 is scoped for 'governing the 4-hour disaster recovery automation logic', meaning it cannot provide immediate failover as designed."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "OC-12",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires roles to be 'continuously rightsized', but Capability C-11 is designed to execute 'periodic least-privilege adjustments', which cannot meet the continuous requirement."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-2",
|
|
"evidence": "Dedicated Private Hybrid Connectivity Gateway (S-2) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-3",
|
|
"evidence": "Centralised Outbound Traffic Inspection and Egress Boundary (S-3) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-6",
|
|
"evidence": "Federated Identity and Role Governance Authority (S-6) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-8",
|
|
"evidence": "Platform Telemetry and Operational Alerting Engine (S-8) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-9",
|
|
"evidence": "Financial Governance and Budget Enforcement Monitor (S-9) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "proposed_addition",
|
|
"attempt": 1,
|
|
"applies_to": "C-13",
|
|
"reason": "The stated effort of 30 hours per month is implausible for 'Continuously analyzing egress inspection logs' on a 24x7 basis. Continuous manual analysis would require full-time dedicated shift coverage far exceeding 30 hours a month.",
|
|
"statement": "Revise the effort for C-13 to reflect the true cost of continuous manual log analysis, or change the basis to rely on automated anomaly alert response rather than continuous manual analysis."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 2,
|
|
"check": "OC-2",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires maintaining an active warm standby ready to receive failover traffic, but Capability C-9 is scoped for 'governing the 4-hour disaster recovery automation logic', meaning it cannot provide immediate failover as designed. Capability C-9 should be revised to govern immediate failover traffic reception."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 2,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-2",
|
|
"evidence": "Dedicated Private Hybrid Connectivity Gateway (S-2) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 2,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-3",
|
|
"evidence": "Centralised Outbound Traffic Inspection and Egress Boundary (S-3) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 2,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-6",
|
|
"evidence": "Federated Identity and Role Governance Authority (S-6) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 2,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-8",
|
|
"evidence": "Platform Telemetry and Operational Alerting Engine (S-8) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 2,
|
|
"check": "SC-change-S-9",
|
|
"evidence": "Financial Governance and Budget Enforcement Monitor (S-9) must be changed. No Capability for making changes covers it with a responsible Role."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 3,
|
|
"check": "OC-11",
|
|
"evidence": "Capability C-7 focuses on configuration state and data residency alignment, but does not cover optimizing carbon-free energy utilization based on regional scores. The Check should be mapped to a deployment capability like C-5 or C-6, or C-7 should be updated."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 4,
|
|
"check": "OC-4",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires handover for workload ingestion within 10 weeks of project start, and is mapped to Capability C-16. However, C-16's basis focuses on roadmap and backlog management and does not mention handover or the 10-week timeline (though C-18 does). The check fails because C-16 does not cover the condition as designed. C-16 should be updated or the check should be mapped to C-18."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 4,
|
|
"check": "OC-11",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires automated deployments to optimize carbon-free energy utilization, and is mapped to C-6. However, C-6's basis only covers managing automated deployment pipelines to deliver foundational updates rapidly and reliably, without mentioning carbon-free energy optimization. C-6 should be updated to include this optimization."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 4,
|
|
"check": "OC-15",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires operations to be delivered entirely under a provider-operated model, and is mapped to C-20 (holding the provider accountable). However, the model assigns C-20 to Provider roles (R-3, R-6) instead of Customer roles. A provider cannot hold itself accountable as the external MSP. Supplier management should be assigned to Customer roles (P-2) to hold the provider accountable."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 4,
|
|
"check": "OC-17",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires Cloud Monitoring alerts to be fully integrated into the provider's event management system, and is mapped to C-2. However, C-2's basis only covers continuous monitoring and alert generation; it does not explicitly mention integrating those alerts into the provider's operational event management system. C-2 should be updated to include this integration."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 5,
|
|
"check": "OC-3",
|
|
"evidence": "Capability C-7 focuses on tracking infrastructure state files and ensuring PCI-DSS v4.0 baseline alignment, but does not mention auditing for UK/EU data residency. Data residency is instead covered by C-21. Capability C-7 should be updated to include auditing data residency state, or the Check should be re-mapped to C-21."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 5,
|
|
"check": "OC-18",
|
|
"evidence": "Capability C-1 covers triage and managing priority incidents, but does not explicitly mention conducting a written review for every Priority 1 incident. The capability basis should be updated to include post-incident written reviews."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 5,
|
|
"check": "OC-21",
|
|
"evidence": "Capability C-4 covers fulfilling non-standard operational requests, but does not explicitly state that each kind of foundation service request has a stated way to ask and a stated time to fulfil (e.g., maintaining a service request catalogue). The capability basis should be updated to include maintaining stated request methods and fulfilment times."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 5,
|
|
"check": "OC-23",
|
|
"evidence": "Capability C-6 covers resolving deployment failures and managing automated pipelines, but does not explicitly guarantee a rollback capability within the 4-hour RTO. The capability should be updated to cover rapid rollback procedures."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 6,
|
|
"check": "OC-2",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires the secondary region to be 'continuously maintained' as an active warm standby, but Capability C-9 is configured for 'business' hours, meaning maintenance cannot be continuous (24x7). C-9 should be 24x7 or another capability should provide continuous maintenance."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 6,
|
|
"check": "OC-4",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires validation within 10 weeks, but Capability C-16 covers managing the roadmap without explicitly mentioning the 10-week requirement (which is instead mentioned in C-18). C-16 must mention the 10-week validation or the check mapped to C-18."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 6,
|
|
"check": "OC-9",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires that expenditure does not exceed target allocations without 'documented operational sign-off', but Capability C-14 only mentions 'escalating anomalies' and does not explicitly guarantee documented sign-off."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 6,
|
|
"check": "OC-12",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires identity permissions to be 'continuously reviewed', but Capability C-11 operates only during 'business' hours, meaning reviews cannot be continuous. C-11 must be 24x7."
|
|
},
|
|
{
|
|
"type": "failed_check",
|
|
"attempt": 6,
|
|
"check": "OC-17",
|
|
"evidence": "The check requires verifiable alignment with DORA, PCI-DSS v4.0, and ISO 27001. Capability C-7 only ensures alignment with PCI-DSS v4.0 baseline configurations, completely missing DORA and ISO 27001 controls."
|
|
}
|
|
]
|
|
} |